Column Overflow Thinking
Make the Biggest and Smallest Numbers

BradIntroduction
Brad can make the largest and smallest numbers with two decimal places, but for the wrong reasons. His reasoning reveals that he has little understanding of place value.

Comments: Text in italics
Interviewer
: Text in red
Brad: Text other colour

Interviewer:
I have a number that starts 3 point something something and you get to choose the rest of the number.

3.--

Interviewer:
Here are the cards to choose from...

3.-- 1234567890

Interviewer:
... marked 0,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8 and 9. I'm going to ask you to make the biggest number that you can by choosing any two of these cards.

3.98

Brad chooses the 9 and the 8

Brad:
98 is the biggest number

Interviewer:
OK, now we'll put those cards back

3.--

Interviewer:
...and could you make another number, this time as small as you can?

Brad makes 3.01

3.01

Interviewer:
OK, and what were you thinking?

Brad:
Well the zero at the start makes it small.

Brad knows that 0.01 is one hundredth, which is smaller than any other number of hundredths or tenths.