Introduction
This interview is based on the game "Hidden
Numbers". Courtney begins by choosing shorter decimals as larger
but after a wrong guess, she looks for zeros after the decimal point.
Confusing decimals with fractions, she wants to know how many parts
a quantity will be divided into.
Comments: Text in italics
Interviewer: Text in red
Courtney: Text other colour
Interviewer:
In this game, you have two mystery numbers and try to guess which is larger. |
Interviewer:
See the decimal point in both numbers?
Courtney:
Yes, I guess I'd better look at the whole
number part first...
Almost all children know to compare the units first.
|
Courtney:
So that's a three...
|
Courtney:
and that's a three too...So I think the
top number is bigger because it's shorter.
Courtney chooses the top number, expecting that as there are
fewer pieces, they must be larger.
|
Her choice was wrong
Courtney:
ohhhh...
|
Interviewer:
Let's try again
Courtney:
OK...I'll just check the first numbers..
|
Courtney:
So I think it will be the top number, but
I'll just check this door...
This time Courtney is more cautious.
|
Courtney is now comparing a 2-digit whole number with a 3-digit
whole number.
Courtney:
Ummm... it's still probably the top number
but I'll just check here..
|
Courtney:
So there are 3 hundred and something pieces
in the bottom number and they would be really small, so I'll choose
the top number...
|
Courtney has been lucky
Courtney:
Great!!!
Interviewer:
Try another one?
Courtney:
Yes
|
Courtney:
I'll open these whole number doors again
to check...
|
Courtney:
I think it's the top number again, but I'll
have to check for zeros after the point. |
Courtney:
Umm..and open this door...
|
Courtney:
This really is a tricky one...I still can't
tell... I guess I'll need to open this door...
Courtney is now comparing two 2-digit whole numbers.
|
Courtney:
...and this door...
|
Courtney:
I still can't tell! This one is a hard one...I'll
open this door next.
|
Courtney:
Well 2 isn't very big so it's probably the
top number again...
Interviewer:
Are you sure about that or do you need to
open the last door?
Courtney:
I guess I still need to check it.
|
Courtney:
They're the same!! That was a trick question!!
Courtney sees both of these as 7 with something divided into
32 parts.
|